"Wasn't given proper diagnosis/management or follow..."

About: St Thomas' Hospital (London)

I attended A&E at St Thomas on Saturday 19th July immediately after sustaining a sports injury to my left knee that morning. I explained to the healthcare professional that I saw that my knee had twisted and collapsed under me whilst playing sport, I heard a loud popping sound, there was immense pain and I was now struggling to walk. I indicated that my knee felt very unstable and I felt something wasn't right. After a lengthy wait, I was assessed by the healthcare professional I was told (in a somewhat condescending tone) that my knee was 'completely fine', 'all ligaments are intact and nothing is ruptured' and that there was 'absolutely nothing wring with my knee'. The healthcare professional advised me to relax, put on a brave face, go home and ice my knee and take painkillers as required. I was not referred on for any further review and I was not advised to seek any further medical advice - I was assured there was nothing wrong with my knee at all and told to leave. I felt as if I had wasted her time. The following week I went to my GP for a second opinion as I did not feel I had obtained accurate diagnosis from A&E and was still in a lot of pain. The GP referred me to a knee clinic who subsequently ordered a MRI. The results of the MRI are that my ACL is fully ruptured as a result of this injury - I am now awaiting ACL reconstruction surgery. This is in huge contrast to the advice received from the A&E healthcare professional who assured me my knee was absolutely fine. I understand that mistakes can be made and diagnosis isn't always easy, but I was disappointed that after waiting 3 hours at A&E, I was told to be braver, take paracetamol and advised in no uncertain terms that there was absolutely nothing structurally wrong with my knee (which is not at all the case). I was not referred for any further assessment or advised to take any further action and was told to go home. Quite frankly, visiting A&E immediately after my injury was a complete waste of time and I don't feel I was given proper management/advice/referral for my injury.

Story from NHS Choices

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››


Response from St Thomas' Hospital

I was concerned to learn about your experiences in A&E. On behalf of Guy’s and St Thomas’, I am very sorry that you were not given the correct diagnosis and for the additional anxiety and pain this has caused. Your comments have been shared with the service management responsible for A&E, who would welcome the opportunity to learn more about your experience and investigate what happened on this occasion. The hospital would need confirmation of your personal details and your consent to investigate. If this is something you would like to pursue – either now or in the future – I hope you will contact PALS on 020 7188 8801 or 020 7188 8803 or by email at pals@gstt.nhs.uk.

  • {{helpful}} of {{total()}} people think this response is helpful